Possible portal targets | Page 7 | The Boneyard

Possible portal targets

Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,113
Reaction Score
6,198
He was not “that good” at ND. I would still love to land him and he is an upgrade. Check out ND forums, they are not sad to see him go and that is an understatement. His nerd number stats are terrible too. I think he graded out as the 90th beat QB last year with PFF.
His playing style and running ability reminds me of Casey Cochran, and I’d say he is a slightly better passer.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
7,344
Reaction Score
24,090
He was not “that good” at ND. I would still love to land him and he is an upgrade. Check out ND forums, they are not sad to see him go and that is an understatement. His nerd number stats are terrible too. I think he graded out as the 90th beat QB last year with PFF.

LOL, it's not surprising that the spoiled with riches ND fanbase would rationalize his leaving as not a big deal. Phluck the ND fanbase! No doubt he wants to go somewhere where he will be appreciated.

His last game versus USC he was 23-26 for 318 yards, 3 TD and 1 Int. 65% completion percentage on the season. He's an accurate passer who can go through a progression quickly and he hasn't come close to peaking as a player. Think Casey Cochran with a better arm. He would be a massive upgrade for us.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Mar 30, 2022
Messages
833
Reaction Score
3,132
LOL, it's not surprising that the spoiled with riches ND fanbase would rationalize his leaving as not a big deal. Phluck the ND fanbase! No doubt he wants to go somewhere where he will be appreciated.

His last game versus USC he was 23-26 for 318 yards, 3 TD and 1 Int. 65% completion percentage on the season. He's an accurate passer who can go through a progression quickly. Think Casey Cochran with a better arm. He would be a game changer for us.

Just be honest
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
5,015
Reaction Score
19,787
His PFF grade and the grades of many freshmen FBS QB’s this year should be below that of Zion Turner when you consider that Turner received scores of offers ( I think around 8 or 9) from many P5 teams. Though it doesn’t mean Morehead isn’t better than Turner right now.
There is a big difference in experience between Morehead and Turner. Morehead is a redshirt freshman and he actually played in 2 games last year. Turner was a true freshman who was not an early enrollee who was thrown into the QB position in late August. Maybe Morehead develops into a really good QB, but coaches are not going to bet their careers on a QB who may develop into a good QB.
 
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,113
Reaction Score
6,198
There is a big difference in experience between Morehead and Turner. Morehead is a redshirt freshman and he actually played in 2 games last year. Turner was a true freshman who was not an early enrollee who was thrown into the QB position in late August. Maybe Morehead develops into a really good QB, but coaches are not going to bet their careers on a QB who may develop into a good QB.
I don’t know he was a redshirt. :oops:
 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,159
Reaction Score
24,807
His stats look good. If you look at PFF grades, Pyne was rated #98 QB with a PFF grade of 69.1. Remember, this was his 3rd year at Notre Dame. Turner, a true freshman, was ranked #145 with a grade of 57.9.

69 > 145, not to mention their are only 130 or so FBS programs. Meaning our starter was worse than backups and FCS QB's.

If the standard is a winning program then yoi can't allow that kind of performance Tyler Phommachanh go unchallenged by outside options.

The other thing we have to offer is a friendly schedule with just enough tough games to put together some good game film. A stud QB that takes a 6-6 UConn to 10-2 will get a combine invite.
 
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
7,344
Reaction Score
24,090
Here's Pyne's season in a nutshell. Very impressive:

Pyne started 10 games this season for the 8-4 Fighting Irish, leading the team to an 8-2 record. His 4-1 record against Top 25 teams was the best by a Notre Dame quarterback in the last 10 years, per Thamel.

Notre Dame inserted Pyne as the starter following the team's upset loss to Marshall. He immediately provided a spark and threw for 2,021 yards, 22 touchdowns and six interceptions while completing 64.6 percent of his passes and ranking 20th in the nation in individual quarterback efficiency.

 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,159
Reaction Score
24,807
Here's Pyne's season in a nutshell. Very impressive:

Pyne started 10 games this season for the 8-4 Fighting Irish, leading the team to an 8-2 record. His 4-1 record against Top 25 teams was the best by a Notre Dame quarterback in the last 10 years, per Thamel.

Notre Dame inserted Pyne as the starter following the team's upset loss to Marshall. He immediately provided a spark and threw for 2,021 yards, 22 touchdowns and six interceptions while completing 64.6 percent of his passes and ranking 20th in the nation in individual quarterback efficiency.

If the HC, OC, OL, WR corps and running game all remain or get better, we have to be an attractive option for a higher caliber QB looking for immediate playing time. If I'm a portal prospect, I look most closely to what the OL looks like.

The only thing we don't have is a P5 schedule, but any QB we're after would not be guaranteed to win a competition at a winning P5 program like they would here.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
22,332
Reaction Score
5,533
As to Pyne, even for the Boneyard this is a stupid discussion. Notre Dame’s standard for a QB being good means he is good for a ranked team’s QB. At the minimum. We haven’t come near an average P-5 QB for an entire season since Dan Orlovsky left. Pyne would be a mammoth upgrade for us from what we had this year or any year in the recent past. (I’m not predicting what ZT will be next year — I’m only comparing to what we’ve had.)
 
Joined
Sep 18, 2011
Messages
5,015
Reaction Score
19,787
69 > 145, not to mention their are only 130 or so FBS programs. Meaning our starter was worse than backups and FCS QB's.

If the standard is a winning program then yoi can't allow that kind of performance Tyler Phommachanh go unchallenged by outside options.

The other thing we have to offer is a friendly schedule with just enough tough games to put together some good game film. A stud QB that takes a 6-6 UConn to 10-2 will get a combine invite.
No FCS QBs in the ratings, but your point is valid that Turner was rated below many FBS QBs and backups. Don't get me wrong, in the portal era, you try to upgrade every position every year including QB. So, if Pyne wants to come to UConn, you take him just like you would take any college QB that has demonstrated decent performance. That said, Turner was a true freshman QB that was was missing most of his offensive weapons due to injuries.

Compare Zion's true freshman year with Dan Orlovsky's true freshman year:

Dan O: 10 games, 128 for 269, 47.6%, 1379 yards, 5.1 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 11 Int., rating: 93.5

Zion Turner: 12 games, 140/231, 60.6%, 1245 yards, 5.4 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 7 Int., rating: 112.7

And Zion played a tougher schedule than Dan O.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
1,226
Reaction Score
1,838
No FCS QBs in the ratings, but your point is valid that Turner was rated below many FBS QBs and backups. Don't get me wrong, in the portal era, you try to upgrade every position every year including QB. So, if Pyne wants to come to UConn, you take him just like you would take any college QB that has demonstrated decent performance. That said, Turner was a true freshman QB that was was missing most of his offensive weapons due to injuries.

Compare Zion's true freshman year with Dan Orlovsky's true freshman year:

Dan O: 10 games, 128 for 269, 47.6%, 1379 yards, 5.1 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 11 Int., rating: 93.5

Zion Turner: 12 games, 140/231, 60.6%, 1245 yards, 5.4 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 7 Int., rating: 112.7

And Zion played a tougher schedule than Dan O.
I think most fans are aware that Turner had lots of things working against him and will likely improve a lot in the off-season. However, he would have to become substantially better just to be as good as Pyne was last year. There's no guarantee that he will make a large improvement and also Pyne is likely to improve as well now that he has lots of game film to analyze his play and improve on the mistakes. The bottom line is that most good football programs have a minimum of 2 quarterbacks that are viable starters. UConn the last 10 years has had none. The staff is trying to have 2-3 guys who could be FBS starters battling for the top position at QB and then have a legit backup so the offense is still effective if there is a major injury to the starter.
 

SubbaBub

Your stupidity is ruining my country.
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
32,159
Reaction Score
24,807
No FCS QBs in the ratings, but your point is valid that Turner was rated below many FBS QBs and backups. Don't get me wrong, in the portal era, you try to upgrade every position every year including QB. So, if Pyne wants to come to UConn, you take him just like you would take any college QB that has demonstrated decent performance. That said, Turner was a true freshman QB that was was missing most of his offensive weapons due to injuries.

Compare Zion's true freshman year with Dan Orlovsky's true freshman year:

Dan O: 10 games, 128 for 269, 47.6%, 1379 yards, 5.1 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 11 Int., rating: 93.5

Zion Turner: 12 games, 140/231, 60.6%, 1245 yards, 5.4 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 7 Int., rating: 112.7

And Zion played a tougher schedule than Dan O.

It's a different game now. Those numbers don't translate for me. DanO was also on a transitioning 1AA team, which then was worse than FCS is now.

Also, our weapons were good enough to carry ZT this season. If ZT has half the mentality that Mora claims, he will get better but there are a ton of red flags that say he won't get better enough to meet the standard. Go get a guy who has done it and let ZT beat him out. I don't see TR or anyone else on the roster as a good enough test.
 
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,113
Reaction Score
6,198
As to Pyne, even for the Boneyard this is a stupid discussion. Notre Dame’s standard for a QB being good means he is good for a ranked team’s QB. At the minimum. We haven’t come near an average P-5 QB for an entire season since Dan Orlovsky left. Pyne would be a mammoth upgrade for us from what we had this year or any year in the recent past. (I’m not predicting what ZT will be next year — I’m only comparing to what we’ve had.)
It’s a few years ago but Zach Frazier comes to mind including his transfer from ND to Storrs. Also Tyler Lorenzen and Tim Boyle come to mind, although Boyle didn’t really seem to hit his stride as a QB until he left UConn.
 
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,113
Reaction Score
6,198
No FCS QBs in the ratings, but your point is valid that Turner was rated below many FBS QBs and backups. Don't get me wrong, in the portal era, you try to upgrade every position every year including QB. So, if Pyne wants to come to UConn, you take him just like you would take any college QB that has demonstrated decent performance. That said, Turner was a true freshman QB that was was missing most of his offensive weapons due to injuries.

Compare Zion's true freshman year with Dan Orlovsky's true freshman year:

Dan O: 10 games, 128 for 269, 47.6%, 1379 yards, 5.1 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 11 Int., rating: 93.5

Zion Turner: 12 games, 140/231, 60.6%, 1245 yards, 5.4 yards per attempt, 9 TDs, 7 Int., rating: 112.7

And Zion played a tougher schedule than Dan O.
Nice post Jim, very hard to argue your point.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
22,332
Reaction Score
5,533
It’s a few years ago but Zach Frazier comes to mind including his transfer from ND to Storrs. Also Tyler Lorenzen and Tim Boyle come to mind, although Boyle didn’t really seem to hit his stride as a QB until he left UConn.
Not one of those played at a level for UConn near what Pyne played at this season. Boyle didn’t play at a level which Pyne played at in high school.
 
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
3,113
Reaction Score
6,198
Not one of those played at a level for UConn near what Pyne played at this season. Boyle didn’t play at a level which Pyne played at in high school.
Oh of course counselor, Boyle was awful in high school too. Only thing Xavier High School did while Boyle was QB at Xavier was win 30 games in a row, dominate the CIAC playoffs, and finish #1 in the state poll two years in a row. Nothing against Pyne, he was a terrific player also in high school, I know that first hand, and he has had a much better college career, but to denigrate one of the states best HS athletes in years, just to make a stupid and iffy point is pretty bad.
 

HuskiesFan1014

Mora excited than before.
Joined
Sep 6, 2011
Messages
1,409
Reaction Score
6,643
Just booked an AirBNB penthouse condo on the ocean. Driving down with Jarhead (maybe i can get him back on the BY) Saturday thru Tuesday. Nothing like an impromptu getaway.
Damn, it feels good to be bowling again! I retired just in time!
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
22,332
Reaction Score
5,533
I
Oh of course counselor, Boyle was awful in high school too. Only thing Xavier High School did while Boyle was QB at Xavier was win 30 games in a row, dominate the CIAC playoffs, and finish #1 in the state poll two years in a row. Nothing against Pyne, he was a terrific player also in high school, I know that first hand, and he has had a much better college career, but to denigrate one of the states best HS athletes in years, just to make a stupid and iffy point is pretty bad.
wasnt knocking Boyle in high school. Didn’t mention Boyle in high school. Did mention Boyle in college where the record speaks for itself
 
Joined
Sep 22, 2011
Messages
2,087
Reaction Score
11,123
LOL, it's not surprising that the spoiled with riches ND fanbase would rationalize his leaving as not a big deal. Phluck the ND fanbase! No doubt he wants to go somewhere where he will be appreciated.

His last game versus USC he was 23-26 for 318 yards, 3 TD and 1 Int. 65% completion percentage on the season. He's an accurate passer who can go through a progression quickly and he hasn't come close to peaking as a player. Think Casey Cochran with a better arm. He would be a massive upgrade for us.
Not that good? The PFF grades are getting out of hand. 22 TDs, 6 INTs and 2200 yards but he stinks?

I get wanting someone more explosive as a runner at the position, but let’s calm down on the PFF grades. I find them ridiculous at times.
 

Online statistics

Members online
474
Guests online
2,793
Total visitors
3,267

Forum statistics

Threads
157,202
Messages
4,087,931
Members
9,983
Latest member
dogsdogsdog


Top Bottom