In my view, Dawn should have won 3 NCs (maybe 4) in the Boston years. Only malign fortune prevented it. Yes, the perimeter shooting was a weakness on those teams, and Iowa exploited it. But it wouldn’t have taken much to go their way for the results to have been very different.
…Dawn may make a few more questionable decisions than her peers. Of course, what I think are mistakes may also be what she has to do to keep a long, very talented bench happy. I haven’t run the numbers, but I think she doesn’t lose much talent to the portal. In fact, even recruiting to a team as loaded as SC takes a sort of genius.
The COVID panic was bigger than a lost chance at a title as a unanimous #1. It cost the Boston class a chance to experience the postseason with a senior All American at point.
Whatever happened in 2020, I’ve always felt a postseason with Ty Harris, who had already won a title, would have helped the then-freshman enough that they would have been more settled in the 2021 Final Four with Stanford.
Tough to say “more questionable decisions than her peers” when her only peers are Geno, VanDerveer, and Mulkey. Dawn’s only 53. She’s a full generation behind Geno and V, and nearly a decade younger than Mulkey.
Geno had established his dynasty by then, but surely he’s learned something since 2008. Fwiw, he had four Naismith+WBCA COY awards at that age. If Dawn wins this year, it would be her fourth composite COY, and a third championship would put her ahead of Mulkey and VanDerveer at the same age.
Believe me, I’m much more critical among Carolina fans than here. But it took a single upset to go from shooting as an Achilles Heel to arguably the best shooting team in the country. Roy Williams retired before making the adjustment. To whatever extent it’s necessary, she’s got time to catch her peers