I don't know. I guess it depends substantially on what the actual question is.
Who'd I like the most to watch as a player? Maybe Selvie.
Who was the best athlete? Maybe Q. Great Q moment. He scores on a tough reverse, fouls on the other end, comes back and hits a 3, intercepts a pass and gets a lay in, loses his guy for a lay in, turns the ball over then steals it back - Rafftery then says, "Montquencio is one of those rare players who can keep both teams in the game at the same time. " Oh lord, I remember spitting out my drink at that.
Who wrote the best pickup truck songs? Clearly Ed.
Who had the greatest UConn spirit? That'd be Rodney.
But who contributed the most to the program, as a whole?
Without Kromah we don't get #4, so, for me, I go with Kromah for that answer.
Kromah was, iirc, 1st off the bench for much of the year, and the started in place of Omar after Omar hit the wall. Giffey took his place in March, but Kromah gave us quality, intense D every game, rebounded hard, and was a decent scoring threat. He also almost never made a bad play to kill momentum - heady with the ball.
The two plays that Kromah made, in the NC game, that will be forever burned into my brain are:
1. Dude comes down in traffic at the Kentucky end with a hand on the ball that a Kentucky player (maybe a twin) has in both hands, directly over his head. Kromah, from an awkward angle, maintains one hand on the ball, all the way to the floor. Ref blows a tie up - OUR ball. Announcers at first think it's a plain foul. I recall Greg Anthony (?) watching the replay and remarking, "no, that's a tie up." Huge, huge play.
2. Late in the game, late in the shot clock, Kentucky sends Kromah's defender to double Bazz at the point. Bazz rifles a pass to Kromah, who has Poythrees (?) coming at him with his 48" vertical. What does the vet do? He pump fakes Porythrees into the air, causing contact the ref must call. He then calmly drills two free throws.
You can trade the rest, and I'm not sure it affects our 4 Natties. No Kromah, we're stuck on 3.