@Yawkey Way I stopped reading your posts after like the 2nd page because you're repetitive like a broken record. A bad one. Nickelback.
On your assertion that BC students/fans would rather play UMass over UConn: A. That's a ridiculous to assume. B. Any chance that BC could play vs UConn AND UMass in a season? Is that too ridiculous for you? C. How would a local rivalry with UConn not benefit BC too? Even if many students are out of state, I can bet there are many sports fans in Boston who marginally care about BC who would route for you guys and provide attendance numbers and revenue.
The rivalry between UConn and BC has died down which might be why you think the students wouldn't care to see you play UConn. I can all but guarantee that would be re-ignited very quickly, and people will be pumped for it when you factor in the inevitable trash-talking, hyping, seeing each other in opposing stadiums, etc. Rivalries are built, and this is one that based on geography and the schools' previous athletic success makes sense.