shizzle787
King Shizzle DCCLXXXVII of the Cesspool
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2015
- Messages
- 12,008
- Reaction Score
- 18,576
Tied for 26th among public colleges with Stony Brook.
Tied for 3rd among public schools in northeast behind Rutgers and Maryland.
Rutgers is a great school whether we like it or not. It is going to be tough to break into the top 40 where it is populated with Ivy, public Ivy, and other well-known private schools.I don’t love being 18 spots behind Rutgers. Wtf happened
The University of Connecticut made the conscious decision to stop playing to the US news and world report criteria. That drops you in the rankings. The fact that we have jumped up makes me wonder if we have reverse that decision. I believe State support is one of the criteria, so that a university would jump up during a building/ expansion phase.I don’t love being 18 spots behind Rutgers. Wtf happened
They changed the criteria, in part because so many schools stopped playing the games.The University of Connecticut made the conscious decision to stop playing to the US news and world report criteria. That drops you in the rankings. The fact that we have jumped up makes me wonder if we have reverse that decision. I believe State support is one of the criteria, so that a university would jump up during a building/ expansion phase.
@upstater knows all the ins and outs of this well. I defer to him if I got any of that wrong.
The University of Florida is a highly competitive University in a large state. RPI, like many like many longstanding, northeast institutions are falling behind universities like UF or the numerous California universities in academic publication and grant based funding.Don’t follow this stuff but any survey that ranks UF significantly ahead of RPI in any category but weather and partying must be seriously flawed
I don’t love being 18 spots behind Rutgers. Wtf happened
Rutgers is surprisingly good academically. It's in the top-5 schools for PhDs on the planet in my wife's field. She got paid 45k a year to go to flippin' Yale and was rejected by Rutgers outright.
For whatever reason we seem to get compared with UMass and UMaryland a lot.
I'd expect the Florida schools to drop in the coming years. Talent is leaving their universities in droves.
It might be related to their reporting data issues this summer. IMO, 'Nova should be bucketed with Wake Forest and North Eastern's of the country, behind BC & BU.I'd like to see us eventually be in that 35-45 tier with Wisconsin, Illinois, and OSU. I'm surprised we're finally ahead of Villanova. They used to be in that BC/BU tier of northeast private schools. Why are they slipping?
I'd like to see us eventually be in that 35-45 tier with Wisconsin, Illinois, and OSU. I'm surprised we're finally ahead of Villanova. They used to be in that BC/BU tier of northeast private schools. Why are they slipping?
These guys change their formulas frequently. They used to be weighted toward student demographics, admissions difficulty and peer ratings. Now, in addition to the beauty pageant that is peer rankings, they are favoring "outcomes." If they used graduate salaries as the primary metric, it would tremendously benefit a school like RPI as mid-career average salary rankings generally put the school well inside the top 25. Engineers make good money. Instead USNWR is heavily weighted toward graduation rates as the measure of outcomes, which benefits schools that offer a wide variety of majors and a highly active social scene. Kids can generally find something they like and, quite frankly, for many they can find something relatively easy. Engineering and the physical sciences are hard (yes, you will study on weekends and no, the weekend doesn't start on Wednesday or Thursday night) and require a high level of passion or commitment, so many kids change majors. At Florida, that would probably mean transferring to another department that's easier or more in line with the student's interests. At RPI and other hardcore STEM schools that generally means transferring to another school. Combine that with the difference in social scene and it's not hard to see why primarily looking at graduation rates benefits a place like Florida. They really aren't comparable schools and the chosen metrics favor one over the other.Don’t follow this stuff but any survey that ranks UF significantly ahead of RPI in any category but weather and partying must be seriously flawed
Curious as to why you would you say Rutgers is surprisingly good academically? Jersey is typically considered to have one of the best public school systems in the country.
Most folks think of Rutgers as a dumpy commuter school where I'm from. It being #3 in the English speaking world in ANY field was a shock to me.
Most folks think of Rutgers as a dumpy commuter school where I'm from. It being #3 in the English speaking world in ANY field was a shock to me.
We could be a top 20 school, and in the AAU with a top 10 football program and not get an “invite”. But BY is going to BY amirite @ZooCougar?Awesome! I’m hoping this will help us get an invite
I'd like to see us eventually be in that 35-45 tier with Wisconsin, Illinois, and OSU. I'm surprised we're finally ahead of Villanova. They used to be in that BC/BU tier of northeast private schools. Why are they slipping?
The US News rankings are not going to get us an invite to anything.
I suspect they’re not worth much of anything, save marketing, but one school that seems to be making strides is USF. Now in the top 100 somewhere and newly AAU.
Also building a new football stadium on campus.
If you want to know where our next realignment nightmare is going to come from, Tampa is a good guess.
Tied for 26th among public colleges with Stony Brook.
Tied for 3rd among public schools in northeast behind Rutgers and Maryland.
Obviously not for hoops. I wonder what they use treasure thst. I would like to see rankings based on grad salaries 2. 5 and 10 years out.
Tied for 26th among public colleges with Stony Brook.
Tied for 3rd among public schools in northeast behind Rutgers and Maryland.
True, but our highest overall finish was 57th previously. More public schools have moved into the 40s and 50s.Don’t forget, we were like #19 or so a few years ago. We started dropping when we stopped playing the game. Not sure what the small bounce back is related to.