Dooley
Done with U-con athletics
- Joined
- Oct 7, 2012
- Messages
- 9,963
- Reaction Score
- 32,822
That's brilliant. When we had not played Florida State, there necessarily was no needle moving from playing Florida State.
The most important factor in our shift away from playing so many games against midwestern teams and doubling, at least, the number of teams we play from the south is recruiting. FL and GA combined produce considerably more D1 football players than all of the BeeOneGee states combined, including NJ and MD.
There is already history of needle pushing when ND plays Florida State, Miami, Georgia Tech and North Carolina. The needle will be pushed when we play Clemson, Virginia and Virginia Tech.
We've played Purdue 85 times and every year since 1946, and ND vs. North Carolina State - not UNC but the number 2 school in the state - will move the national needle at least as much as ND vs. Purdue.
Perhaps the main reason is that southern football is simply much better than northern football.
Personally, I couldn't care less about Notre Dame and their motives for wanting to play in the ACC vs B1G. I'm simply replying to your statement that I bolded. Yes, right now, southern football is better than northern football. There is absolutely no disputing that at all - championships don't lie and there is no disputing the success that southern college football has had in the past decade +. Sports are cyclical though. So we have to ask why southern football is better than northern football. I've got a few potential reasons (my opinion, nothing more):
- uptempo offenses will, for the most part, favor southern football. When there is absolutely zero weather concern during the season (maybe 1 game per season), it is much easier to run an uptempo speed game than it is in the north. Now, that doesn't explain why Oregon is so successful at running a high octane offense. I guess there are exceptions to the rule (not to mention, Oregon recruits southern CA very heavily), but the majority of uptempo offenses in the south are going to be able to run it much more smoothly than in the north when they do not have to worry about the elements. High school factories in the south can therefore prep their kids appropriately all year. High school factories in the north, which traditionally produced the better (but slower) OL/DL and strength prospects, are growing more and more obsolete as the game continues to get faster.
- the rules favor uptempo offenses, for now. This applies across all levels of football, right on up to the pros. Defensive players aren't allowed to touch receivers, they can only hit in certain areas of the body (safety concerns are justified), defenses can not substitute players who are gasping for air without using a precious timeout, and defensive players who are injured are booed relentless and face a possible penalty for delay of game so there is real pressure to fight through. Thus far, all of the safety rules passed favor offense. Offenses are allowed to pick (albeit through a disguised "route") defensive players and, as we saw with Aqib Talib in the AFC Championship Game, injure. If the same contact went the other way (Talib hit Welker), he gets a flag. Granted, the same set of rules apply to both northern and southern football so maybe southern football has been quicker to adapt to the changes than northern football. But let's see what happens when somebody finally figures out that it is equally as dangerous to play defensive football as it is to be on offense and some rules are introduced to slow down the game. It is almost criminal that defenses aren't allowed to substitute out a player who is having an asthma attack or who got injured 3 plays ago but it isn't quite serious enough to warrant going down. Protecting the defensive player is every bit as important as protecting the offensive player...it just hasn't been adopted yet because there is more money to be made by allowing uptempo offense. And while conferences and schools make money on uptempo offense, this will be slow to change.
- big games are all located in climate controlled venues. The one very real advantage northern football has over southern football is playing in the elements. I LOVE that this past Super Bowl was held in New York/New Jersey. I hope that the college game follows the NFL's lead and alternates playoff games in northern venues that are not protected from the weather outside. There is no reason, if schedules align, why games can't be played at Soldier Field or MetLife Stadium. I want to see southern schools play in the elements, the way football is made to be played. I want to see uptempo offenses be forced into adjusting their game plans to incorporate more of a power ground game because the footing isn't there to continue to be pass-happy. At some point, you have to think that the college game will test it out like the NFL did last year and play a big game in the north. When that day happens, I think you will see a leveling off. Had Notre Dame played Alabama at Soldier Field or MetLife in early January, then I would wager a hefty sum that the game would have been MUCH closer than it was.
These are my opinions. There is no doubt that southern football is the rule of the roost right now. That said, rules change constantly and as a fan of a northern football school, I hope that they do. I realize that offense boosts ratings but there has to be a way to give defenses a fighting chance. Perhaps there could be a 5-10 second substitution period before the play clock starts between plays to allow for each side to make an unpenalized substitution? When you slow the game and put more emphasis on a power running game, you should start to see a more equal playing field between north and southern football. And how about the buzz/ratings that would come from a Playoff game played in the snow? I'd watch that the same way I love to watch NFL games played in extreme weather and I know I wouldn't be alone.
You can't blame Notre Dame for taking advantage of their sweetheart deal and moving football to the ACC. If UCONN had a sweetheart deal where we had our own TV deal and a conference that made us a very generous offer to play their schools while being able to remain Independent to make our TV millions, I'd want that too. Tapping into southern high school football will be huge for them and allow for Notre Dame to play more of a "southern" style of game with smaller but faster players. Since that's the trend of today's football, it's smart for Notre Dame to align with a southern presence. And let's be honest, the ACC offers Notre Dame a selection of MUCH easier opponents to play against than the SEC does. It's really a no-brainer for them.
Anyway, I've wasted enough energy thinking about Notre Dame. Go UCONN!